Start by ensuring both options are meant for the same axle position, drive, and the same type of mixed-service work. Next, compare whether each model is offered in the exact size you need, such as 9.50-16.5 or 12-16.5, and confirm wheel diameter compatibility. Then consider tread style suitability for your routes, including how much time is spent on loose surfaces versus pavement. Finally, factor in operational considerations like availability for consistent fleet replacement. A decision based on fitment, application match, and supply consistency is typically more reliable than choosing by name alone.