Introduction
The debate between all-weather and all-season tires confuses many drivers when it comes to choosing the right tire type. Both of them are often seen as synonyms. However, all-season and all-weather tires do have certain differences that make them more suitable for specific weather conditions. This section aims to shed light on the specifics of the 2 types of tires to help you make the right choice depending on the conditions in which you drive.
What Are All-Season Tires?
All-season tires are specially crafted to deliver decent performance in various conditions throughout the year. Their specificity consists of balancing the traction and grip capacities both in wet and dry conditions. Also, all-season tires are designed to cope adequately and safely in light snow conditions.
1.1.A/S Tires Key Features
All-season tires are generally characterized by 3 specific aspects. These include:
- Symmetrical tread patterns (in most cases)
- Harder rubber compounds (compared to summer tires, to withstand cold conditions)
- Moderate tread depth (to stay reliable on various road surfaces)
1.2. A/S Tires Pros
All-season tires are an option of choice for drivers who usually roll in mild weather conditions. This includes but is not limited to moderate temperatures both cold and hot, wet and dry. In such conditions, all-season tires deliver:
- Fairy long tread life
- Dependable performance
- Decent fuel efficiency
1.3. A/S Tires Cons
All-season tires are designed for moderate weather conditions, not for extreme ones. Due to their specific formula and design, all-season tires do not perform as well as summer/winter tires in the following conditions:
- severe winter conditions with packed and deep snow as their tread is not able to bite effectively through snow and ice
- extreme heat as their rubber formula is not meant for extreme temperatures, leading to less grip
1.4. Specific Symbols
The "S+M" symbol on a tire sidewall is usually the clue suggesting that it is part of the "all-season" class. It stands for Mud & Snow which refers to mild and light winter conditions.
All-season tires are more of a compromise between winter and summer tires. These borrow some capabilities from dedicated tires but never perform better in extreme conditions. NHTSA describes them as "tires that provide a balance of performance in wet and dry conditions, as well as some winter capability". Here is what the "M+S" symbol looks like on an all-season tire:
1.5. Popular All-Season Tires Include:
2. What Are All-Weather Tires?
All-weather tires are a more recent branch in the tire industry. Their goal is to fill the gap between all-season and winter tires. This means they are equally versatile in various weather and road surfaces but benefit from a more confident and safer performance in severe winter conditions.
2.1. All-Weather Tires Key Features
All-weather tires are quite similar to A/S tires, except that they have additional elements that improve their winter performance. Thus, their characteristics look as follows:
- Softer rubber compounds to maintain traction in severe winter
- Deeper tread depth to grip better in deep snow
- More aggressive tread patterns to bite snow and ice surfaces
2.2. All-Weather Tires Pros
All-weather tires are a good option for drivers who circulate in areas with a changing climate from warm-moderate to severe winter. These tires bring the following advantages in the named conditions:
- dependable performance in ice and snow
- reliable year-round traction
- versatile in use as these eliminate the need for seasonal tire replacement
2.3. All-Weather Tires Cons:
All-weather tires have a slightly different rubber formula and architecture from all-season ones. While these tires perform better in winter, this benefit entails some trade-offs as the following:
- Slightly less fuel-efficiency
- Shorter tread life compared to all-season tires
2.4. Specific Symbols
Unlike A/S, all-weather tires are certified for use in severe snow conditions. The proof of certification is the 3PMSF symbol on the sidewall of these tires which confirms the tested reliability of the product in extreme winter conditions.
2.5. Popular All-Weather Tires Include:
3. Performance Comparison
3.1. Dry Conditions
Most reliable sources like Yokohama and Lesschwab suggest that all-season tires generally deliver higher performance in dry conditions. This is explained by their less aggressive architecture and harder compound that allows them to grip better on dry surfaces. In addition, they are easily distinguished by better driving quality on dry and warm surfaces and precise handling.
3.2. Wet Conditions
Both types of tires have excellent characteristics and features to demonstrate impressive and dependable wet handling. Some sources slightly favor all-weather tires because their deeper and more aggressive tread patterns contribute to the efficient channeling of water/slush and hydroplaning control.
3.3. Snow and Ice
All-season tires yield significantly to all-weather tires in terms of snow and ice performance. According to the Tire and Rubber Association of Canada- "All-weather tires provide cold-weather performance that is superior to an all-season tire and is comparable to a winter tire". This translates into a higher grip on snow, shorter braking distance, more confident acceleration, and safer cornering in extreme winter conditions.
3.4. Summer Heat
The harder formula of all-season tires allows them to withstand high temperatures better than that of all-weather tires. The softer compound of all-weather tires increases their rolling resistance in the summer heat, making handling less responsive and increasing fuel consumption.
4. US-Specific Considerations
4.1. Regional Climate Variations
The territory of the United States is subject to a rich climatic variation from the hot Southeast to the snowy Northeast. Drivers are encouraged to choose their tires according to their local climate. The following recommendations might be considered:
- Southeast and Southwest: All-season tires might be more than enough due to milder winters;
- Northeast and Midwest: All-weather tires might be a better year-round choice considering the harsh winters in these areas;
- Pacific Northwest: All-weather tires can be beneficial due to frequent rain and occasional snow.
4.2. State Regulations
Every driver should familiarize himself with the specific tire regulations in their areas for winter driving. Some US states have strict requirements, which cancel the option of choosing between all-season and all-weather tires. For example, Colorado's Traction Law requires all vehicles to have either snow tires, all-weather tires (with the 3PMSF symbol), or carry traction devices in certain periods of the year. In such conditions, all-season tires might not be the best option.
5. Making Your Choice
The choice between all-season and all-weather tires, as in the case of any other type, must be taken consciously, taking into account at least 4 aspects. Here is what we encourage you to consider:
- Your local climate and specific weather changes
- Your driving habits and road conditions
- Your proneness to change tires seasonally
- Your vehicle type and its technical capabilities
All-season tires are generally sufficient for most US drivers, considering the moderate climates on most of the territory. However, all-weather tires will deliver much more safety and reliability for drivers in areas with severe winters.
Conclusion
While they seem similar, all-season and all-weather tires do have particular features that make them more suitable for specific conditions. Understanding the differences is crucial to ensure optimal performance and maximum safety on the road. Both of them stand out through year-round versatility and decent performance skills. However, all-weather tires give more peace of mind when driving in areas where snow and ice are a real challenge.
Why Trust Us?
The NeoTires team is dedicated not only to the best tire deals but also to tire education. We offer truthful information to drivers so that the risks associated with driving decrease as much as possible. For this purpose, we have gathered specialists in the field in our team who share their experience regarding tires and everything related to their use and safety.
Our goal is to bring valuable and validated content to our customers and readers. For this, we collaborate with experts in the field as well as perform our own tests. We are a reliable source of information and a technical center dedicated to analysis and research without being sponsored, aided, or influenced by any brand or dealer. Learn more about our history and culture here. Drive safe and choose your tires wisely!
